“Branching plotlines.” The phrase is so evocative. Personally, it makes me think of a huge, gorgeous oak tree that you can’t help but climb. The further up the tree you get, the more enveloped in its leaves, its world, you become. Eventually, having scaled the rough bark and felt the twigs scraping past your forearms and face, you find yourself completely surrounded by a whole verdant universe.
That’s sort of what it’s like when a video game has a branching plotline that really works. You keep making choices based on the realities of the game, and with each choice you make you venture that much further into the mythology, the systems, the history and the logic of whatever game you’re playing. I call these often-thrilling moments in games “decision points.”
(Since we didn’t hear from the lawyers / literary agents of George W. Bush after I used the phrase extensively in my last piece, I’m assuming that he’s not only refraining from filing any kind of lawsuit regarding my use of the phrase, but that also his silence is a kind of tacit approval.)
Now, imagine that same tree as before. But some branches of the tree are rotted through, dead, and instead of helping take you deeper into the depths of the great oak, they snap if you put your weight on them and you fall a hundred feet back to the ground, back to the real world, where you have problems like work responsibilities, financial concerns and the fact that you’ve just broken three ribs and shattered your pelvis after falling from a tree.
Just as well-crafted decision points immerse you deeper into a game, less masterfully constructed decision points pull you out. They make you confused, frustrated or disinterested. But why? Well, it can be for a number of reasons.
Spoilers ahead for The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, Skyrim and the original Baldur’s Gate.
____
BALDUR’S GATE – DON’T BLOW ME OFF
I hesitate to put this on here, because the original Baldur’s Gate and its wildly cool sequel are two of the reasons I got into RPGs in the first place. But, alas, I must be honest, and this decision point was one I didn’t even understand until I was ankle deep in hamster blood.
Let me explain. Like everybody else who ever played these games, I loved the insane barbarian Minsc and his pet hamster Boo. Not only was he a funny character with tons of personality, but he was my party’s heavy.
When you first meet Minsc, he tells you that he is sworn to protect a sorceress who has been captured by gnolls. Pretty standard D&D stuff. You agree, sure you’ll kill the gnolls, but first you’ve really got to level up and get cooler swords and clear all these stupid kobolds out of this mine.
So Minsc goes with you, and he helps you out with whatever you’re doing. And after a while he mentions, “Hey, remember that sorceress? Me and my space hamster blah blah blah.”
During my play-through I brushed him off, assuming that like every other quest in pretty much every other RPG ever, I could get around to this when I felt like it. But then, after another short while, Minsc flips out. He decides we’ve been using him, and he attacks the entire party. There’s no reasoning with him – it’s too late for that. He’s furious and that cool sword I gave him is now being used to cut us all up. We’ve got no choice but to kill him (and, presumably, his hamster).
When I looked online for help with the quest, I got the response from franchise loyalists that I was simply paying for choices that I had made. But I call bullshit on this and every decision point like it, where you have a limited span to make a choice and you don’t know it. Unless you establish very early in your game that actions will be on a timer, and certain quests will expire or change significantly depending on that timer, then you have to assume I will blissfully spend years of in-game time trolling the countryside looking for bandits to eviscerate. Nearly the entirety of video game history has trained me to take time for granted, and so I think a little more warning isn’t unreasonable when I ought to be in a hurry.
THE WITCHER 2 – SHE’S A GOD DAMN SUCCUBUS
In The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings, main character Geralt of Rivia runs into a lot of monsters. It’s sort of his thing. But when a monster you face tries to talk itself out of a battle, Geralt turns from warrior to detective.
The succubus quest in this game plays out like a Law and Order: SVU episode written by Neil Gaiman on speed. You are tipped off that a succubus has made her lair underneath the town, and sure enough she has. However, when confronted with your suspicion that she has been killing young men she adamantly denies it, saying while she draws lifeforce from her lovers / victims, dead men are no good to her. She accuses a former lover who was overly smitten with her, and became jealous when she seduced other men.
Over the course of this quest you exhume bodies, take statements and write poetry, all in search of what really killed these men. Then you are forced to either accuse the succubus or her former lover. Little do you know that only after you accuse one or the other will the truth become known, and then only if you have chosen correctly. Otherwise, you’ll have to live with your choice, wondering in vain what the hell all that succubus business was about.
SKYRIM – WAR, WHAT IS IT GOOD FOR?
I surrendered huge spans of my life to Skyrim. If I had spent every hour I played Skyrim learning foreign languages, I would be working at the UN. And I don’t regret a second of it. Skyrim is more open-world than a lot of the games I’m focusing on here, but there are still big choices to be made about who your character sides with in any given conflict, and who your character wants to be in this gigantic realm.
But one large portion of Skyrim felt hollow to me, and it’s the portion I would have assumed would be the most interesting – the civil war between the imperialist forces and the native rebels. There’s certainly a lot at stake here, including civil rights, self-determination, Tamriel’s balance of power and freedom of religion. However, for all the subjects that this conflict covers, your part in whatever outcome occurs speaks to shockingly few of them.
When you choose a side to fight for in the battle for Skyrim, you are assigned basic missions where you gather artifacts and take enemy strongholds. The lore behind the politics involved is deep, but once you’ve thrown in with a certain faction, you see very few of these big ideas carried through to a satisfying climax. You don’t get to ream Ulfric Stormcloak about the terrible treatment of the dunmer under his reign, and you can’t tell General Tullius that restricting the Nord culture is idiotic. Even though the game goes out of its way to show you how the conflict is anything but black and white, once you join the conflict on either side, you become little more than an order-following war machine.
____
I had a friend tell me recently that he was reluctant to recommend a linear game to me, because he knew how much I loved the participatory nature of open-world or player-influenced plots. I told him, no, I could enjoy games that didn’t give you a bevy of dialogue options or multiple endings. And it’s true — a really great story, even a static one, still shines even to the most committed advocate of heightened player autonomy in all areas. The formative games of my youth were titles like Metal Gear Solid and The Legend of Zelda: a Link to the Past, both games that told affecting stories where your only input as a player was helping the protagonists survive.
But the samples above (flawed decision points cherry-picked from very good games) do make clear to me that the sensation of control, of choice, is an absolutely key part of the future of games. Decision points bring you directly into the thematic material of a game, and in so doing they make you directly party to any deeper meaning that the game is able to produce. When exercised awkwardly, these mechanics are unimpressive; when put to good use, they are some of the strongest unique powers the medium has.
Filed Under: Adventure Editorial Humor Reflections Role-playing Story-driven
About the Author:
Aaron Matteson is a stage actor in Brooklyn, a Seattle native, and an alum of Village Voice Media's Joystick Division.
39 Responses to “Decision Points II: Decision Pointier”
Leave a Reply
The Latest:
Originals
Swan SongThis is a tough one to write. For those of you who know me, in person, by my writing, or…
Originals
The Fool and the Villain, Part II(Warning: In Second Life, pixelated tits and dicks abound. Abandon all hope, all ye who enter this article at work.)…
Commentary
The Edge Of The OceanThe problem is to plot the map. My sense of geography is spotted with black holes. There’s the Chinatown and…
Originals
Play EverythingPlay everything. No, I’m serious, play everything. Play that game of hopscotch those kids drew up on the sidewalk with…
Commentary
Genre In QuestionWhy are there so few video game comedies? At least twice in the past year I’ve bumped into conversations trying…
what exactly was the problem with the witcher 2 quest? i thought that that was possibly one of the best quests in any game, period. The whole point of the game is that you have to live with the decisions you make, and that in exchange for what you get, you miss out on something else. the way you describe the quest sounds like excellent advertisement for that aspect, and i didn’t actually get any sense of complaint from it at all, certainly nothing like the other two anecdotes.
Taxi moto line
128 Rue la Boétie
75008 Paris
+33 6 51 612 712
Taxi moto paris
I love reading through a post that will make men and women think.
Also, thanks for allowing for me to comment!
http://bio-catalyst.com/ – minocin tablets
zyvox generic
clindamycin for sale vantin generic
side effects for cialis generic cialis
generic cialis no doctor’s prescription https://edplsgeneric.com/ buy cialis
cialis cost coffee with cialis
generic cialis tadalafil cialis erection penis
what is cialis used for https://edplsgeneric.com/ cialis pills for sale
liquid cialis source reviews cialis patent expiration
30ml liquid cialis cialis without a doctor prescription
low cost cialis https://edplsgeneric.com/ cialis coupon
cialis tolerance how much does cialis cost
cialis patent expiration cialis before and after
coupons for cialis http://cialisirt.com/ how does cialis work
cialis pills what is cialis used for
fda warning list cialis cialis 30 day trial coupon
cialis vs levitra http://cialisirt.com/ how long does 20mg cialis keep in system
30 day cialis trial offer purchasing cialis on the internet
cialis canada the effects of cialis on women
cialis pills http://cialisirt.com/ lowest price cialis
buy viagra cialis current cost of cialis 5mg cvs
how does cialis work cialis in canada
canadien cialis http://cialisirt.com/ buy cialis
free cialis canadian viagra cialis
how long does 20mg cialis keep in system how often to take 10mg cialis
legitimate cialis by mail http://cialisirt.com/ cost of cialis 20mg tablets
cialis vs viagra effectiveness cialis prices
cialis 30 day trial voucher cialis vs viagra
side effects for cialis http://cialisirt.com/ when will cialis go generic
walgreens price for cialis 20mg free cialis medication for providers
30 day cialis trial offer how does cialis work
low cost cialis http://cialisirt.com/ cialis in canada
cialis erections 5mg cialis
cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis generic
cialis side effects http://cialisirt.com/ generic cialis black 800mg
is generic cialis safe the effects of cialis on women
how long does it take cialis to take effect cialis erection penis
cialis or viagra https://edplsgeneric.com/ real cialis without a doctor prescription
liquid cialis source reviews 30 day cialis trial offer
canadian viagra cialis coupons for cialis
cost of cialis 20mg tablets http://cialisirt.com/ legitimate cialis by mail
cialis 20 image does medicaid cover cialis
cialis without doctor prescription 30 day cialis trial offer
buy cialis online https://edplsgeneric.com/ free cialis
where to get cialis sample cialis in canada
cheapest cialis average price cialis
coffee with cialis https://edplsgeneric.com/ cialis 20 image
fastest delivery of cialis buying online daily use cialis cost
samples of cialis cialis before and after
cialis at a discount price https://edplsgeneric.com/ real cialis online with paypal
cialis without a doctor’s prescription cialis lowest price 20mg
cialis samples request generic names for cialis and viagra
cialis 200mg http://cialisirt.com/ cialis prices
real cialis without a doctor prescription buy cialis online canadian
tadalafil daily use https://nextadalafil.com/ tadalafil tablets tadalafil 30 mg
tadalafil online https://pulmoprestadalafil.com/ tadalafil pills generic tadalafil 40 mg
generic tadalafil https://extratadalafill.com/ tadalafil dosage tadalafil online
tadalafil 30 mg https://superactivetadalafil.com/ what is tadalafil tadalafil 40 mg from india
tadalafil tablets https://tadalafilgenc.com/ tadalafil tablets tadalafil pills
tadalafil 60 mg for sale https://nextadalafil.com/ tadalafil generic tadalafil online
tadalafil 40 https://pulmoprestadalafil.com/ generic tadalafil tadalafil 40 mg daily
tadalafil pills https://extratadalafill.com/ tadalafil max dose tadalafil pills 20mg
tadalafil https://superactivetadalafil.com/ tadalafil max dose 40 mg tadalafil
tadalafil pills 20mg https://tadalafilgenc.com/ tadalafil tadalafil online
generic tadalafil 40 mg https://tadalafilgenc.com/ order tadalafil tadalafil max dose
tadalafil pills 20mg https://pulmoprestadalafil.com/ tadalafil pills tadalafil online
tadalafil online https://extratadalafill.com/ tadalafil 40 tadalafil generic
tadalafil https://superactivetadalafil.com/ tadalafil 40 mg daily buy tadalafil
order tadalafil https://pulmoprestadalafil.com/ tadalafil 30 mg tadalafil gel
buy tadalafil us https://nextadalafil.com/ generic tadalafil united states tadalafil 30 mg
tadalafil tablets https://extratadalafill.com/ tadalafil 60 mg for sale tadalafil 30 mg
tadalafil alcohol tadalafil research chemical tadalafil citrate
tadalafil price at walmart cialis 20 mg tadalafil troche