Originals

07/30/2012

Sugar From Shit

Bad mechanics making great games

By: Rowan Kaiser

Filed Under: Mechanics Psychological

Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas is one of the worst games I’ve ever played, according the logical part of my brain.

The logical part of my brain is wrong, of course. I played San Andreas to completion, and enjoyed it. It’s my second-most-played Steam game. (I’m hardly alone in my enjoyment, it’s the best-selling Playstation 2 game and one which has received rave reviews across the board.) And yet, if I try to use that analytic part of my brain to understand what makes San Andreas work, it seems like a disaster.

Its shooting system is mediocre at best. It’s filled with frustratingly simplistic mini-games, like the most basic rhythm-game sections imaginable. The driving is the best of the oft-used mechanics, but it rarely rises above competent, and several of the cars handle wildly. Flying vehicles, on the other hand, switch between boring and horrifically frustrating, and are often mandatory for quests. The quests themselves range wildly in difficulty and length, and tough, long ones—such as one where, 2/3s of the way through the mission, you have to pilot a completely new kind of airplane—don’t include checkpoints, for maximum frustration. The plot is ludicrous, which can be fun, but it also lacks any sort of depth.

The only component of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas that works for me, without any caveats, is its collection of early-1990s radio stations. The music and DJ chatter set the mood that helps build the entire game world. It makes me want to be part of the game, and explore all the interesting and not-so-interesting parts of the game world. San Andreas and games like it are built in an expansive fashion. Here’s a game that’s trying, and often failing, to let your character steal planes like cars, go on dates, recreate Ocean’s Eleven, go on killing sprees, or race from L.A. to San Francisco, or just dance in a club. It’s experimenting with what can be done with the form of video games, and that often means—demands, really—that some parts are going to be fucked up.

I like this expansiveness. I like the daring, the ambition, the crazy gaps in the story or the world or the gameplay that somehow make things better, not worse.

It’s not just for games, either. One of my all-time favorite albums is Television’s Marquee Moon, a beautiful mess of an album, part punk, part jazz, part prog-rock. Not every song is a winner. I even skip the sixth and seventh tracks, “Prove It” and “Guiding Light,” during most listens to the album. Television’s other album released before breaking up, Adventure, is better all-around when I rate each song in my MP3 player. It doesn’t have the weak tracks, and everything works. But Adventure inspires respect, not love from me (or most other critics and fans).

This applies with television shows, as opposed to bands, as well. Sure, and elegantly constructed drama like The Wire and Game Of Thrones are among my favorites. But I don’t get that feeling of obsession with them like I have the wild experiments in the form like Babylon 5, Buffy The Vampire Slayer, or Community. Which leads me to wonder why. Was the form of the band that made Marquee Moon and Buffy more experimental and interesting? Or does my brain actually prefer media with “bad” bits so that I can focus more easily on the “good” parts?

The same thing drives me away from games that aren’t expansive. When I play Gears Of War or Batman: Arkham City, I have to respect the craft that goes into the games. I even enjoy playing them! But I typically only enjoy them in hour-long sittings, rarely compelled to go back. They’re too slick, too intentional, too controlled. These are games where it feels like the developers had a very good idea of what technology was available, what kinds of games and stories worked within those technological (and market) constraints, and create the best possible product within those constraints. I have to force myself to finish them. On the other side, oh lord do I not have to force myself to sit down with Civilization V for what ends up seeming like days at a time, even though I have a checklist of complaints about that game that rivals my annoyances with GTA: San Andreas.

As I write this, I want to play Mass Effect. I’ve wanted to replay the series since I finished the third game, months ago. I’ve wanted to replay it despite considering the ending a total betrayal. I’ve wanted to replay it despite having huge issues with every single part of it, from overall plot to mechanics to mission structure. But here’s the problem. The Mass Effect series isn’t in the part of my mind that can break things down into component parts. It’s firmly lodged in whatever section of my brain loves science fiction. Just as I can’t necessarily explain why Assassin’s Creed doesn’t do much for me despite liking most of the mechanics, I have difficulties explaining what makes Mass Effect so great when there’s so much wrong with it.

Perhaps psychology has an answer. The phenomenon of “cognitive dissonance” describes what happens when people hold two conflicting beliefs at the same time. When actions reveal this discrepancy, the person must nonconsciously create an explanation for their behavior. In a famous study, two groups of people were given a boring task. One was paid enough for it to be worth their time, another was barely paid. When polled, the latter group described the task as more enjoyable. Why? The theory is that, when confronted with the conflicting thoughts of “I don’t do boring things” with “I just did a boring thing,” the easiest resolution was  “it actually wasn’t that boring!” The other group didn’t have that conflict—they could easy say “I did a boring thing, but for money.”

The lesson here isn’t simply that playing “bad” games long enough helps us think that they’re good—I’ve given up on plenty of outright bad or unappealing games. It’s that our brains are designed to fill in gaps that justify our behavior. And, when it comes to video games, my theory is this: the bigger the gaps, the more the brain has to do to fill them. The more work the brain does for the game, the more love the owner of that brain will have for it.

But, in order to make this process work, the game has to do something well. It has to have great radio stations like San Andreas. It can be a paradise of destruction, like Red Faction: Guerrilla, Far Cry 2 or Just Cause 2, or a paradise of beauty like Skyrim. It doesn’t have to be open-world: Mass Effect isn’t, but it has superb voice acting and occasionally fantastic action. It’s almost guaranteed in the best strategy games, like Civilization or Shogun 2, thanks to their successful action/feedback loop. Or it can just be something fresh, like the original Doom, or in love with its own playfulness, like the best Mario games from Bros. to Galaxy. They’re expansive games, trying to do something interesting more than doing something slick. They’re the games worth falling in love with, damn the flaws.

[art credit]

Filed Under: Mechanics Psychological

About the Author:
Rowan Kaiser is a freelance pop culture critic currently living in the Bay Area. He is a contributing writer at The A.V. Club, covering television and literature. He also writes about video games for several different publications, including Joystiq, Gameranx, and Unwinnable.

12,097 Responses to “Sugar From Shit”

  1. JMZoss

    Nice piece. I’m on the same page with you on many of the games you mentioned. Like you, I respect the polish and precision of the Gears games without actually “liking” them.

    The Dead Space games are both titles that have brought me back despite their flaws. Neither a particularly great action game nor particularly scary. But there’s something about the audio design (oh those zero-G segments) and the universe of the series that just clicks with me.

  2. James Hawkins

    Yeah I agree with you about the Dead Space games except I find them both scary and loaded with good action. So I guess they wouldn’t fit in this category.

    I will say that I was absolutely blown away by Metro 2033 — a game I wrote off when it was released and only purchased and played on impulse. There’s a lot of naive level design, but you’re in a world that’s meant to be confusing. It works. The tacit contract between player and game that promises mechanics will work consistently throughout is breached frequently. But it feels designed that way – an unreliable world yields unreliable results. Very, very cool.

  3. M. Joshua Cauller

    This absolutely captures the growing fundamental flaw with the average consumer’s obsession with arbitrary scores within review systems. Even if a game is “perfect,” it doesn’t necessarily capture the flavor you’re hungry for. Nice stuff.

  4. Douglas Scheinberg

    There’s a certain game on the original Game Boy called Great Greed that I have a similar relationship with. The game has absolutely no right to be as enjoyable as it is; in just about every technical aspect, it’s lacking, but it somehow adds up into something so incredibly charming and just plain fun that I can’t help loving it.

  5. Nike Running Shoes

    LeBron James Signature Sneakers: Ranking the Best of the King,lebron 1 retro | NIKE LEBRON bestairjordansuscheaps2021- LeBron James Shoes,Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men for Sale | Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes & Sneakers.
    Nike Running Shoes

  6. New Air Jordan Shoes

    Jordan retro 4 collection | bestairjordansuscheaps2021 Jordan Retro 4 Shoes | Air Jordan Sneakers |The Jordan Retro 4 is the shoe that Michael Jordan wore when he drained ‘the shot’ during the 1989 NBA playoffs. Air Jordan 4 Shoes | Jordan Retro 4 Releases and Classics.
    New Air Jordan Shoes

  7. Anonymous

    Real Jordans Shoes: bestairjordansuscheaps2021 Authentic Cheap Jordan Shoes,Find Real Cheap Jordans Online Outlet Store, The Latest Jordan Shoes Release Jordan Retro 11 Jordan Retro Shoes | Air Jordan Retro Sneakers | Get Huge Selection & Low Prices on Jordan Cheap.

  8. Jordan Shoes 9

    Air Jordan 11 Sneakers bestairjordansuscheaps2021| Buy Cheap Air Jordan 11 Retro “Concord” For Sale Online,It is arguably one of the most loved Jordan styles. The Benefits Of Buying The Air Jordan Retro 11 (XI) Concord. Cheap Air Jordan 11 鈥?New Jordans 2020.
    Jordan Shoes 9

  9. Anonymous

    Air Jordan Shoes: Air Jordans bestairjordansuscheaps2021 | Retro Jordan | Cheap Jordan,offers the top quality Jordan Shoes and Cheap Jordan Shoes Free Shipping.Real Cheap Jordans, Original 37$ Cheap Jordan Shoes!

  10. Anonymous

    LeBron James sneaker; bestairjordansuscheaps2021 original lebron shoes NIKE LEBRON SOLDIER XIII SFG EP; original lebron shoes Nike LeBron James Shoe Line History.Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes & Sneakers | His latest sneaker, the LeBron 18 is designed to maximize speed and power.

  11. Anonymous

    Not only bestairjordansuscheaps2021 is the best team in the West playing basketball once again, but LeBron James is apparently debuting his latest signature sneaker,Find great deals on Nike LeBron James Sneakers for Men when you shop the huge selection of new & used sneakers.

  12. Anonymous

    Cheap Air Jordans For Sale | bestairjordansuscheaps2021 Cheap Jordan Shoes Online,Top Quality Real Cheap Air Jordans, Discount Retro Jordans Sale Free Shipping!cheap jordans for sale,cheap jordans-Original Cheap Jordans Online Store,Supply Men Jordans,Women Jordans For Sale,Cheap Jordans For Kids With 60% discount!

  13. Nike Shox R4

    Not only bestairjordansuscheaps2021 is the best team in the West playing basketball once again, but LeBron James is apparently debuting his latest signature sneaker,Find great deals on Nike LeBron James Sneakers for Men when you shop the huge selection of new & used sneakers.
    Nike Shox R4

  14. Anonymous

    LeBron James Signature Sneakers: Ranking the Best of the King,lebron 1 retro | NIKE LEBRON bestairjordansuscheaps2021- LeBron James Shoes,Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men for Sale | Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes & Sneakers.

  15. Nike KD Shoes

    Cheap Jordans for Sale, bestairjordansuscheaps2021 Buy Air Jordan Shoes Online,Cheap Air Jordans for Sale. 2020 Newest Cheap Air Jordan Retro Shoes Up To 50% Off. Real Cheap Air Jordans Retro Sale for Men, Women and Kids. Buy Cheap Authentic Nike Jordan Shoes, Air Jordans Retro Online with Top Quality!
    Nike KD Shoes

  16. Anonymous

    Nike LeBron James Sneakers for Men for Sale | Find great deals on Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men bestairjordansuscheaps2021 … genuine authentic nike lebron xvi low mens size 8 w/original box.LeBron James is a generational talent.
    [url=http://www.cheaprealairjordans.com/][/url]

  17. Anonymous

    Nike LeBron James Sneakers for Men for Sale | Find great deals on Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men bestairjordansuscheaps2021 … genuine authentic nike lebron xvi low mens size 8 w/original box.LeBron James is a generational talent.
    [url=http://www.newairjordansretro.com/nba-basketball-shoes-c-1.html][/url]

  18. Anonymous

    Shop bestairjordansuscheaps2021 men’s basketball shoes top brands like Nike and more. Find all the latest styles and brands that will help you own the court! Men’s Basketball Shoes | nike basketball shoes -Find the best Nike Basketball shoes from LeBron, Kobe, and Kevin Durant.
    [url=http://www.cheaprealairjordanshoes.com/new-air-jordan-retro-c-51.html][/url]

  19. New Jordan Shoes For Women

    Shop bestairjordansuscheaps2021 cheap Nike Lebron James Basketball Shoes Free Shipping. Shop the latest Nike Lebron James Sneakers, including the LeBron 16 ‘Four Horsemen’ and more.Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men for Sale.
    New Jordan Shoes For Women [url=http://www.cheaprealairjordans.com/new-jordan-shoes-for-women-c-66.html]New Jordan Shoes For Women[/url]

  20. Original Lebron Shoes

    Lebron James: bestairjordansuscheaps2021 Every Sneaker He’s Has Worn in his NBA career,Nike LeBron 1 shoes at the best price on StockX, the live marketplace for 100% real Nike sneakers and other popular new releases.
    Original Lebron Shoes [url=http://www.originallebronshoes.com/]Original Lebron Shoes[/url]

  21. Jordans On Sale

    LeBron James Signature Sneakers: Ranking the Best of the King,lebron 1 retro | NIKE LEBRON bestairjordansuscheaps2021- LeBron James Shoes,Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men for Sale | Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes & Sneakers.
    Jordans On Sale [url=http://www.cheaprealjordansonsale.com/]Jordans On Sale[/url]

  22. Jordan Shoes 9

    Shop bestairjordansuscheaps2021 cheap Nike Lebron James Basketball Shoes Free Shipping. Shop the latest Nike Lebron James Sneakers, including the LeBron 16 ‘Four Horsemen’ and more.Nike LeBron James Basketball Shoes for Men for Sale.
    Jordan Shoes 9 [url=http://www.cheap2019jordanshoes.com/jordan-shoes-9-c-5.html]Jordan Shoes 9[/url]

  23. shapewear plus size

    Plus Size Bodycon Dresses. For your next special occasion, choose a plus size bodycon dress from Esaning.com. Bodycon means body confidence, and these dresses are designed to display that confidence with a figure-hugging silhouette.Bodycon is a fashion-forward style of dress that fits snugly against the body and shows off your curves. a wide selection of cute, tight homecoming dresses in all the current trends, so you’re sure to find the best dress for your own personal style.
    shapewear plus size

  24. drugs used for Headache problems

    Thanks for your tips. One thing we have noticed is always that banks and also financial institutions have in mind the spending behavior of consumers and also understand that a lot of people max out there their own credit cards around the holiday seasons. They prudently take advantage of this kind of fact and begin flooding the inbox and also snail-mail box together with hundreds of Zero APR card offers immediately after the holiday season comes to an end. Knowing that in case you are like 98% of all American open public, you’ll hop at the possiblity to consolidate personal credit card debt and move balances for 0 interest rates credit cards. hgggfil https://headachemedi.com – drugs used for Headache problems

  25. buy thyroid drugs

    Thanks for your suggestions. One thing I’ve noticed is the fact that banks as well as financial institutions really know the spending routines of consumers as well as understand that most of the people max out there their real credit cards around the getaways. They properly take advantage of this specific fact and commence flooding your current inbox along with snail-mail box using hundreds of no-interest APR card offers just after the holiday season comes to an end. Knowing that should you be like 98% of American community, you’ll rush at the possiblity to consolidate card debt and shift balances for 0 apr interest rates credit cards. jiihhjm https://thyroidmedi.com – generic thyroid medicine

  26. best stomach medications

    Thanks for your suggestions. One thing I’ve noticed is the fact that banks as well as financial institutions really know the spending routines of consumers as well as understand that many people max away their own credit cards around the vacations. They sensibly take advantage of this particular fact and begin flooding your own inbox as well as snail-mail box along with hundreds of Zero APR credit card offers right after the holiday season finishes. Knowing that if you’re like 98% of all American open public, you’ll leap at the opportunity to consolidate credit debt and move balances to 0 annual percentage rates credit cards. eeeedgj https://stomachmedi.com – best stomach medications

  27. stomach drugs for sale

    Thanks for your tips. One thing we have noticed is always that banks and also financial institutions have in mind the spending behavior of consumers and also understand that a lot of people max away their own credit cards around the holiday seasons. They smartly take advantage of that fact and commence flooding ones inbox in addition to snail-mail box having hundreds of no-interest APR credit cards offers shortly after the holiday season concludes. Knowing that for anyone who is like 98% of American community, you’ll soar at the possible opportunity to consolidate consumer credit card debt and shift balances towards 0 interest rate credit cards. lkkjjln https://pancreasmedi.com – how to relieve ulcer pain immediately

  28. prescription for psoriasis

    Today, with the fast lifestyle that everyone leads, credit cards have a huge demand in the economy. Persons from every field are using the credit card and people who are not using the card have lined up to apply for one. Thanks for sharing your ideas on credit cards. https://psoriasismedi.com prescription for psoriasis

  29. medication for bronchitis

    I wanted to compose a note so as to express gratitude to you for some of the marvelous pointers you are posting here. My long internet lookup has at the end of the day been paid with high-quality ideas to share with my family and friends. I ‘d express that most of us site visitors actually are truly endowed to dwell in a magnificent place with so many marvellous people with insightful pointers. I feel rather grateful to have encountered your web site and look forward to really more entertaining moments reading here. Thanks once again for all the details. https://bronchitismed.com buy bronchitis drugs over the counter

  30. drugs used to treat bronchitis

    I just wanted to make a quick note so as to express gratitude to you for some of the marvelous points you are posting here. My long internet lookup has at the end of the day been paid with incredibly good ideas to share with my family members. I ‘d express that most of us site visitors actually are rather endowed to dwell in a good network with many lovely individuals with great methods. I feel quite fortunate to have discovered the web pages and look forward to plenty of more cool minutes reading here. Thank you again for a lot of things. https://bronchitismed.com bronchitis meds

  31. strzykawki

    Dzięki za wskazówek dotyczących naprawy kredytu na temat tego blogu. Rzeczy i chciałbym rada ludziom byłoby, aby zrezygnować z rzeczywistej mentalności że będą teraz i wypłać później. As a as be a} społeczeństwo {my|my wszyscy|my wszyscy|wielu z nas|większość z nas|większość ludzi} ma tendencję do {robienia tego|robienia tamtego|próbowania tego|zdarzyć się|powtórz to} dla wielu {rzeczy|problemów|czynników}. Obejmuje to {wakacje|wakacje|wypady|wyjazdy wakacyjne|wycieczki|rodzinne wakacje}, meble, {i|jak również|a także|wraz z|oprócz|plus} przedmiotów {chcemy|chcielibyśmy|życzymy|chcielibyśmy|naprawdę chcielibyśmy to mieć}. Jednak {musisz|musisz|powinieneś|powinieneś chcieć|wskazane jest, aby|musisz} oddzielić {swoje|swoje|to|twoje obecne|swoje|osoby} chcą {od wszystkich|z potrzeb|z}. {Kiedy jesteś|Kiedy jesteś|Kiedy jesteś|Jeśli jesteś|Tak długo, jak jesteś|Kiedy} pracujesz, aby {poprawić swój kredyt|poprawić swoją zdolność kredytową|zwiększyć swój kredyt|zwiększyć swój kredyt|podnieś swój ranking kredytowy|popraw swój kredyt} wynik {musisz zrobić|zrobić|faktycznie potrzebujesz|naprawdę musisz} dokonać kilku {poświęceń|kompromisów}. Na przykład {możesz|możesz|możesz|możesz|będziesz mógł|| możesz|prawdopodobnie możesz} robić zakupy online {aby zaoszczędzić pieniądze|aby zaoszczędzić pieniądze|aby zaoszczędzić} lub {możesz przejść do|może się zwrócić|może odwiedzić|może obejrzeć|może sprawdzić|może kliknąć} używane {sklepy|sklepy|detaliści|sprzedawcy|punkty sprzedaży|dostawcy} zamiast {drogie|drogie|drogie|drogie|drogie|drogich} domów towarowych {dla|w odniesieniu do|dotyczących|odnoszących się do|przeznaczonych dla|do zdobycia} odzieży {strzykawki insulinowe 1ml|strzykawki tuberkulinowe|strzykawki|strzykawka|strzykawki insulinowe|strzykawki do insuliny|strzykawki trzyczęściowe tuberkulinowe|strzykawka tuberkulinowa|strzykawka insulinowa|strzykawka do insuliny|strzykawka trzyczęściowe tuberkulinowa} {strzykawki insulinowe 1ml|strzykawki tuberkulinowe|strzykawki|strzykawka|strzykawki insulinowe|strzykawki do insuliny|strzykawki trzyczęściowe tuberkulinowe|strzykawka tuberkulinowa|strzykawka insulinowa|strzykawka do insuliny|strzykawka trzyczęściowe tuberkulinowa}.

  32. asmr https://0mniartist.tumblr.com

    Hi would you mind letting me know which webhost you’re
    working with? I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different internet
    browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most.
    Can you suggest a good web hosting provider at a honest price?
    Thank you, I appreciate it! 0mniartist asmr

  33. 0mniartist

    Good web site you have here.. It’s difficult
    to find quality writing like yours nowadays.
    I seriously appreciate people like you! Take care!!
    0mniartist asmr

  34. bit.ly

    If you are going for finest contents like I do, simply go
    to see this web page all the time as it presents quality
    contents, thanks asmr 0mniartist

  35. bit.ly

    Hi there friends, pleasant post and fastidious arguments commented here, I am really enjoying by these.
    asmr 0mniartist

  36. Forklift For Sale Los Angeles

    Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve visited this web site before but after going through a few of the posts I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m certainly delighted I discovered it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back frequently!

  37. gamefly are

    Hi there just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few
    of the images aren’t loading correctly. I’m not sure
    why but I think its a linking issue. I’ve tried it in two different internet browsers and both
    show the same outcome.

  38. asmr my

    Excellent goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous
    to and you’re just too magnificent. I really like what you have
    acquired here, really like what you are saying and the
    way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep it wise.
    I can’t wait to read far more from you. This is actually a tremendous web site.

  39. asmr off

    Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed!
    Very useful information specifically the last part
    🙂 I care for such information a lot. I
    was seeking this particular info for a long time. Thank
    you and best of luck.

  40. or asmr

    I like the valuable information you supply for your articles.
    I will bookmark your weblog and take a look at once more right here
    regularly. I’m quite sure I will learn many new stuff right here!

    Good luck for the next!

  41. gamefly the

    Excellent way of describing, and good article to get data regarding my presentation subject, which i am going to present in school.

  42. it asmr

    Hi! Someone in my Facebook group shared this site with us so I came to take a look.
    I’m definitely enjoying the information. I’m book-marking and will
    be tweeting this to my followers! Excellent blog and great style and
    design.

  43. Peterzoolo

    buy cialis now ed pills – buy cialis without perscription
    cheapest generic cialis australia

  44. http://j.mp/

    Post writing is also a fun, if you be familiar with after that you can write otherwise it is
    complicated to write.

  45. on asmr

    If you are going for finest contents like me, simply go to see this web page daily
    because it presents quality contents, thanks

Leave a Reply

  • (will not be published)

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

The Latest:

  • Originals

    Swan Song

    This is a tough one to write. For those of you who know me, in person, by my writing, or…


  • Originals

    The Fool and the Villain, Part II

    (Warning: In Second Life, pixelated tits and dicks abound. Abandon all hope, all ye who enter this article at work.)…


  • Commentary

    The Edge Of The Ocean

    The problem is to plot the map. My sense of geography is spotted with black holes. There’s the Chinatown and…


  • Originals

    Play Everything

    Play everything. No, I’m serious, play everything. Play that game of hopscotch those kids drew up on the sidewalk with…


  • Commentary

    Genre In Question

    Why are there so few video game comedies? At least twice in the past year I’ve bumped into conversations trying…